“A Letter always seemed to me like Immortality, for is it not the Mind alone, without corporeal friend?” - Emily Dickinson\, poet\, in an 1882 letter In December 1843, Henry Cole was drowning in post, and he had only himself to blame. Three years earlier he’d helped launch the Penny Post, which made sending a letter cheap enough for almost anyone. Almost anyone promptly did, and a good many of them wrote to Henry Cole, who felt obliged to write back. So he asked his friend, the painter John Callcott Horsley, for a shortcut. On 17 December his diary notes: “In the Evg Horsley came & brought his design for Christmas Cards.” It showed a family gathered round a table raising a toast. Cole had 1,000 printed, used what he needed and sold the rest at a shilling each, which was a stiff price at the time. It caused a small scandal. Among the family raising their glasses was a young child happily drinking wine, and temperance campaigners were furious. The V&A says the card was judged a commercial flop, which seems a little harsh on something that sold at auction in 2013 for £22,000. The idea wouldn’t go away, though. Today Americans alone send more than a billion Christmas cards a year, and somewhere along the way Cole’s shortcut turned into something rather more valuable. Bills, statements and junk mail get opened with a sigh, but a Christmas card is the one piece of post people actually look forward to opening. It took marketers a while to notice, but once they did, some of them made remarkable cards. In 2012 BMW Switzerland put an a cappella group in a car, drove it at nearly 250 km/h and recorded them singing “Jingle Bells” as they went. About 3,000 Swiss BMW drivers received the result on a Christmas card with a sound chip, and 1.2 million more people watched it online. Four years later, Doctors of the World and McCann London went somewhere much darker. Their set of Christmas cards placed traditional nativity scenes among photographs of that year’s wars in the Middle East, a reminder that the real Holy Land looked nothing like the one on the mantelpiece. Donations came in 336% above target. Cadbury found the gentlest version of all. Its Secret Santa Postal Service let people send someone a bar of chocolate anonymously in the run-up to Christmas, and in 2021, for every bar sent, Cadbury gave a second one to a food bank in the Trussell Trust network. The sender got to be generous twice, and only had to sign their name once. Actually, they didn’t have to sign it at all. All three lean on an instinct psychologists call reciprocity: when someone gives us something, we feel a tug to give something back. In the 1970s the sociologist Phillip Kunz tested it by sending Christmas cards to about 600 complete strangers. Around one in five wrote back, some with letters three or four pages long, apparently untroubled that they had no idea who he was. In 2015 the psychologist Brian Meier tried the same experiment with 755 Americans, and only 2% replied. My guess is that the tug is still there, but we’ve become very good at spotting a card that was sent to everybody. A printed signature from the whole office stirs about as much gratitude as a gas bill. So if you’re sending cards this year, for your business or your family, the lesson from 180 years of Christmas post is to make each one something nobody else could have received. One handwritten line about something only the two of you know will do more than the most expensive design, and if the card gives them something to keep, or a small way to do some good, it might even earn a spot on the mantelpiece. Henry Cole only wanted to save himself some writing. He ended up inventing the one piece of post people are glad to get, as long as somebody has bothered to write in it. Want more on why small gestures move people? Our Behavioural Science for Brands course is a lovely place to start.